Reviews

Rate Show
More than 5 stars and now what can be done?
MOST POWERFUL EPISODE OF ANY PODCAST I HAVE EVER HEARD. Update: Jake. I have NEVER heard anything more real, compelling, and demanding of attention. Thank you Gilbert. This story changed me. Thank you for Telling this story…. What can we do? WHAT CAN WE DO?
Heartfelt & told with compassion
Many thanks to Gilbert King, Kelsey Decker and all of the members of the team who put together this amazing Podcast. At this story’s core is the power of forgiveness, which is the way forward for anyone who has experienced trauma in life. Thanks again for exposing an astonishing , unforgettable set of events. Don’t miss listening to it.
fantastic
This one is going in my favorite podcasts of all time.
The first first
The only first time time thing is I is a going out to to get get a some thing food for the family family dinner dinner for for the
Complicated
This is a complicated story. It’s so heartbreaking to listen to Jeremy talk about the struggles he had throughout his life and the hopelessness knowing he will spend his life in prison. At the same time, he didn’t just murder one person in a fit of rage or stupidity. He murdered four people and it’s hard not to think, he’s exactly where he needs to be. Those four people deserve justice.
John Aguero
Domestic abuser, arrogant prosecutor operating outside the law. May he rest with no peace whatsoever.
Surprising
I listened to Season 1, and had no desire to listen to Season 2. I listened to The Prosecutors also, and they urged everyone to listen to Bone Valley with season 3 coming up. I typically agree with them, so I did it. It is one of the most powerful stories of forgiveness and faith. I loved every minute of it. All I can say is WOW!
touching
appreciated all the effort put into this podcast. it was moving that justin was able to repair parts of him through reconnecting as there seems to be change and growth in jeremy. just wish there was more about the struggles and suffering from michelle’s family. i understand that all involved are victims of something, but michelle is thee victim in this story as she did not get a chance to grow and live her life. many women live in constant fear from the violence of men they know and of strangers, and it’s constantly brushed off as a phase that men go through. and the abusers get to claim they are not proud of their actions many years later and everyone just tiptoes around the subject as if it’s too painful for the abusers to be questioned more about it. it’s really not highlighted enough in general and in this story, which will only help normalize violence and framing of such matters. i love a redemption arc and forgiveness as much as anyone else, but hopefully next season there will be more examination of the causes of abuse and violence towards women and what it was that made them change their way of thinking. i firmly believe there is a lot of regret from all parties involved but i am hoping they will expand more to be accountable to the ones who suffered most like michelle, michelle’s loved ones, jami, and justin.
There are no words..
I cannot even put into words how powerful this entire podcast is.. I kept a lump in my throat through it all.. along with tears and smiles. Just incredible..
Emotionally challenging
I struggle to put into words how this second season challenged my heart. I didn’t want to feel sympathy for Jeremy, but wow, my heart aches for him. I thank you, Gilbert/Kelsey/team, for all the work you have poured into helping, Leo/Jeremy/Justin/Jaime. You have my highest admiration. May God bless you and the work you do.
A must listen for everyone . . .
This is hands-down one of the most powerful podcast experiences of my entire life, showcasing the worst and best sides of humanity, and exploring the very depths of forgiveness and redemption and love.
Kindness and Forgiveness
Just finished Season 2 with son Justin and Jeremy writing letters. I am crying and smiling and loving this turn of events. I want to continue to hear more of their stories… Leo, Justin, Jeremy.
A must listen
This was a great telling of the injustice done to an innocent man, and the coming to terms of another man and his crimes, and guilt.
Must listen
Perfection. Hopefully Leo’s redemption story is not over…
Fantastic Podcast
Well now I’m sobbing through the second season. This is an incredibly heartbreaking and complicated story and this podcast does an amazing job telling a nuanced story with empathy. Investigative journalism at its finest, excellent sound production. The music is also incredible- bravo Leo. Florida is trash and so is our justice system. I really hope Leo gets justice.
Devastating and beautiful
Rarely does any work of art encompass the reality of the best and worst of humanity so evenly and so brutally honestly. Season two is quite possibly the most compelling podcast I’ve ever heard, and I’ve heard a lot.
Captivating
Really powerful and inspiring. People are incredibly complicated. I’m left feeling the humanity and healing.
So good!
Do not pass this one up. It’s so good from start to finish. Both seasons!!
Fabulous Story
Gilbert King is phenomenal in his storytelling of the lifer of this brokenhearted, but remorseful man. I would love a season 3 where Justin, Jeromy and Leo can all meet. Thank you Mr. King
Second time listening S1
Powerful story. Deeply touching. I’m sobbing, at awe. Can’t express how much this podcast has helped me throughout some difficult emotional time. One of the best podcasts I’ve ever listened. Thank you so much for such a wonderful job.
Brilliant.
Wow. Just an unbelievably well told story about a tragedy that ends with hope and healing. This is so well written. A classic example of how a podcast can create a space for something positive to grow…. Even in the worst conditions.
Amazing
The best podcast I’ve ever listened to. This isn’t a true crime podcast. This is a podcast of love, redemption, and grace in the midst of a corrupt system.
Theme song
I love the theme song. The fact that it’s written by Leo and another guy in prison just touches my heart so much. All the things that Leo has accomplished behind bars is amazing. The fact that he prayed for Jeremy and you shared the contrast of Leo wanting to kill him understandably versus started praying for him and asking for prayer and then the near immediate change inJeremy. I cried, and I shared it with my husband, and he teared up. It was amazing and I love that you’re continuing Jeremy‘s story. Yes he is a murderer, but everyone has a redemption story and everyone deserves love.
season 2
none of us is the worse thing we've done. none of us is the worst thing we've experienced.