Reviews

wait hold awn… this is tew good. my fave podcast and i’m not even a podcast person like that

Honestly so good

Definitely worth listening to!

Apparently cops are just as messed up in Kentucky as they are in Florida. This story is BONKERS, and I’m not even sure how it ends because this Quincy guy is STILL IN PRISON! Another must hear story. Seems like 6 episodes is to few.

I was gripped the whole way through!! A must must must listen!!

This is such a beautiful and painful story. The team did such good work. This last episode leaves me with hope for a father and son and a heavy and hardened heart for this “justice and legal” system. Thank you for all the hard work and sleepless nights to get this out. Bravo!

Just when I thought I heard everything - I started season 3. Wowwwww

Very thorough narrative by Maggie Frelang of her deep investigation of Kentucky law enforcement's handling of a heinous crime. She is determined to defend the innocent until proven guilty.

Loved seasons one and two! Season three is just as riveting. Totally binge worthy. Great job!

Seasons one and two were incredible— thoughtfully done, and captivating. This third season isn’t Bone Valley. This should just be its own show. Maggie Freleng seems insensitive and a bit disjointed. Great editing though! Also why did you mess up Leo’s song?!

Fantastic investigative journalism and storytelling!

The injustice here is just mind-boggling. It's so unfair Leo is still in jail. Gilbert and Kelsey did a super job telling this story.

Highly recommend this podcast. It does a great job going into the depths of corruption in the political justice system (hopefully Polk County has made some changes for the better?) and I guarantee the evolution of relationships will touch your heart and soul. What a beautiful story of family, faith, humanity, friendship, growth and love. I am a huge fan and so proud of the people in this story who have overcome so many obstacles to do the right thing. You had me in tears of happiness!

Very good podcast

Gut wrenching!!! We have the most f-ed up criminal justice system. The frustration I felt when listening to to season 1 was beyond unfair. I’m just starting season 2 and if it’s as stunningly produced, super-bingeable, and so incredibly heartbreaking and heartwarming at the same time, then I’m in for a treat!!!

S2- Ugh! It’s beautiful and heartbreaking and conflicting all at the same time. He brutally murdered many people and disregarded their lives. He didn’t care if they got a true burial and grave and yet wants someone to bury him respectfully. It’s such a confusing and conflicting situation but one that shows forgiveness and grace, compassion and love. He should be beyond thankful and proud of his son! S1- It’s heartbreaking to know innocent men and women are in prison and with such negligence and pure disregard for human life by the men and women who are sworn in to protect and serve. The land of the free… Leo is such a strong man and deserves all the happiness in the world.

Gilbert is a great storyteller and I’m glad he took on the challenge to help Leo and to make this podcast but, his hard-on for “the state of Florida” and his bias against law enforcement can be cringe at times. I guess it’s just typical agenda spouting which most of these podcasts are but someone should have edited dome of it out. Otherwise I thought it was excellent and would definitely recommend it.

If you are a fan of the work of Susan Simpson, Maggie Freleng, or Rabia Chaudry, you will love this podcast. The writing is phenomenal, the research is impeccable. Your heart will be ripped out over and over as you realize the depths of injustice that our system imparts upon people. Kelsey, Gilbert, you did such an amazing job.

Excellent storytelling with music that also enhances - not overwhelmes - the piece. Exhaustive reporting, great host.

One of the most touching podcasts that I've listened to. Leo is one of the cases that made me take a look at our justice system and after nearly learning a similar fate due to lies and corruption I decided to return to school and study law. If not for our local law school and their support and dedication I wouldn't be where I am today. I intend to represent those who cannot afford proper representation and fight for the wrongly convicted. If you need ideas for another season I highly recommend looking into Keith Zon Doolin’s case as that is the other case that still today gives me nightmares and makes me question if teaching our children to be helpful and good Samaritans is a good thing or not. It made me question what I should tell my sons to do if they see a woman or women possibly in danger and what the right advice is to give. I know they say innocent people shouldn't worry but in fact, innocent people should essentially be more concerned about injustices. Circumstantial evidence is all in the way that one perceives it and that can be a tricky and dangerous game to play. Sadly states all too often disagree to admit that they made a mistake or to correct it. The same thing happened with Keith, while another heinous murder led to not 1 but 2 suicides related evidence including a detailed confession is sealed and Governor Newsom refuses to allow for the truth. Keith is on Death Row and I fear that California will never right this wrong and sickening injustice. Keep up the amazing work that you're doing!! You changed many lives with your podcast and gave us the raw and emotional aspects of what you're doing. I hope you truly know what a blessing you have been for many people and families. I look forward to hearing what is to come in future seasons.

One of my favorite podcasts of all time. Wonderful storytelling.

5 star show. Great show. So well done. But I do have one thing to nitpick- can we knock it off with the true crime podcast buffer music? And we def don’t need a full min of it at the start of every episode. Stop trying to manipulate emotions and just deliver the story. Okay, rant over. Again, great show!

Such a riveting, heartbreaking, well done podcast. Excellent work!

That was an amazing story!