Reviews

Rate Show
Happy
I’m happy that I listened to the most recent podcasts first. Listening to the early ones and the phony white privilege installed in the episodes was ridiculous. Finally on track and presenting facts and not phony ideology.
Great podcast
Erica Kelly, I would just like to share with you how much I am enjoying your southern fried true crime podcast. I found you by listening to Crime Junkie and The Deck. Which is a blessing because I needed some new binge worthy crime podcast to do for a few days. I love the way you tell your stories, you have such a perfect, soft voice for podcast listeners, and the first time I listened to your podcast. I was an immediate subscriber. Thank you for sharing your knowledge and stories with us. And myself, as a listener, I would like to thank your husband for building you that soundproof room in order for you to do these. Keep up the fabulous work. It is wonderful. 💜Nahnee💜
Shadow MacLaine
Just want to correct the military status here. Shadow did not retire from the military, she ETS’d which is End Termination of Service. To retire is 20+ years.
Pay option
I sure do wish there was a pay option, rather than listening to the NUMEROUS, and ever-increasing number of ads. It’s difficult to relax, and enjoy the podcast, then bam…it’s an ad…it’s loud, and even sometimes in Spanish, which I don’t even understand. Please offer some way to NOT hear the ads. I love the podcast, and have reviewed before.
So great!
Thank you all for your hard work and diligence in having an honest podcast that truly cares about the victims. Erica- love your straightforward personality!
Recommend for True Crime Fans
I just discovered this podcast. I love it. Highly recommend to anyone who is a true crime fanatic. I live in the south so southern true crime is fascinating to me and Erica delivers.
LOVE YOUR PODCAST
I have listened to your podcasts for a long time, have enjoyed them. I am curious why you added background music. I find it irritating, it adds nothing to the podcast and I think it is distracting and takes away from the podcast. Enjoy the podcasts but not the background music
Excellent storyteller but lose the Muzak background
Great voice and excellent writing.My only criticism is the song playing in background. Its out of hand. It’s just strange to play it over and over and over under the narration, don’t understand why. I am curious since it adds nothing and is irritating (like Muzak, you can ignore it most of the time but other times the tune just plucks at my nerves). Why is it there? Why do you think anyone needs to hear it non stop on repeat? Do you think it’s that good? Did one of your kids write it? Do you want to irritate your listeners? Did someone tell you it makes your podcast better? When I can’t ignore it I just have to turn this off. I don’t get it! I do appreciate your storytelling. I love how racist white listeners just hate freedom of speech when they don’t agree with you.
Mackle case
Loved your telling of this incident . My father testified on the hair and fiber evidence for the FBI on this case. He was just remembering it and sharing more details.
Fantastic
Excuse me while I gush for a minute, but I’ve got to gush. I’ve listened to many episodes of this podcast over the last year or two and love all of them. This particular episode my 17 yo daughter was in the car with me as I listened. It was her first time hearing the podcast and I could tell she wasn’t thrilled at first. She’s use to very dramatic tellings of stories/crimes/whatever in the podcast she listens to and Erica isn’t like that. Erica is calm with her retelling of what happened in each crime. She is respectful of the victims and isn’t sensational about the crimes. She paints a detailed picture of what happened with her words in a soothing, southern drawl. Like buttermilk cornbread and side of gravy at Sunday supper, Erica gives the details that complete each episode without adding unnecessary off the cuff commentary. Within ten minutes I could see that my daughter was immersed in the episode. We stopped it a few times to discuss what to do in different situations discussed, as well as for her to google photos of those involved. All of Erica’s episodes are well researched with sources sited, so it’s easy to find things like photos, books, articles, etc. We got home with 20 minutes left, and I fully expected my daughter to jump out of the car to go inside but was thrilled when she wanted to finish the episode. Shes ADHD, and not easy to get her to sit still to do anything once her addy has worn off for the day, but she didn’t move a muscle until it was over. That’s an insanely huge compliment in itself. I’ve never been disappointed with an episode or in how Erica tells the victims story. I suspect I never will be disappointed either.
Great podcast!
I just recently discovered this podcast and I love it! Your voice is so soothing to me , a fellow southern from NC. I am binging this from the beginning !
Addicted
Safe to say I'm hooked!! Started yesterday and already on episode #9. So good!!
Love this podcast and Erica!
I can’t wait to get into my car Monday morning for my LA commute to work ( I know sounds strange ) because SFTC latest podcast is out. It’s the little things in life that keep me going! Love Erica’s voice and the way she tells the story.
Excellent show
One of the best shows out there!
🎉👍🏻
Love the content. Love the delivery. LONG time listener from Louisiana. Kellye R. CenLAw Podcast
Love her podcast
I really do! BUT this is a podcast and most people listen with some version of earbuds/headphones. Since that is the case WHY are the commercials so much louder??? I am going through menopause and have discovered that if I listen to podcast at night with AirPods, when I wake up for no apparent reason 10000 times, I can focus on the talking and usually go back to sleep. Best thing ever!!! Except YOUR commercials are SO much louder than the show that wakes me up. And that pisses me off!! Why is that a thing??
Best story teller
I love this podcast so much. There is no fluff or silliness. Erica has a calming yet serious voice which I feel is so appropriate when talking about true crime and paying respect to victims. She is an amazing story teller and I so appreciate the research she does. This has been my go to podcast for a couple of years when I’m in between series.
Best Podcast
Erica Kelley could read case law out loud and make it interesting! These shows are well researched……I have been personally connected to one of these stories and found out more than I knew myself from this podcast. This is the only podcast I never miss…
Great Storyteller
Erica works hard to ensure the victims are not forgotten, she is willing to speak on the ugly parts of our society, and her voice is very soothing despite the nature of the stories.
Great podcast
Was recommended by fellow true crime followers and I love this podcast. Love the non nonsense style. Will recommend to others
lots of humanity...
she’s just the best…i love that she has a point of view and NEVER forgets the victims…plus she loves Dolly…just like the rest of us…
Excellent and on point!
Love Erica’s solid research and compassion for the victims and their families. Her worldview clearly shows an educated and progressive woman. Wonderful podcast. 10/10
Voice from the South
I love this podcast!!
Love love love
Erica’s voice is so relaxing to me. She does in-depth research on each case, and lets the listener come to their own conclusion. Erica makes me proud to be Southern.
Great story telling
Very annoying background noises
Love love
Living just an hour north of Nashville, I absolutely love her accent. It’s as though I’m listening to my neighbors tell a story. I listen while cleaning and doing outside gardening, mowing, chores and such. I look forward to each episode! I’m giving This podcast a five star rating!! Great job! Keep up the good work.
Dixie Mafia
Love your episodes but the Dixie Mafia episodes, I was hoping to hear about the Georgia version, Billy Sunday Burt and Billy Wayne Davis crew. I’ve heard other podcasts about them and they are very interesting.
The very best
I listen to five or so true crime pods. Find Ms Kelly shines at deep dive, vocabulary, lovely accent articulation and overall intelligence. Enjoy her occasional movie reviews which are occasionally relevant to case she’s discussing. And her southern expressions. Very charming.
Ok-if I’m murdered EK, I need you to tell my story.
Seriously, just listen to her. Her stories are so kind to the victims (that’s super important to me) and don’t glorify the violence (also super important). Her empathy is apparent in her voice and yes, I am southern so she she sounds like home. But before the naysayers write her off without giving a listen, EK is from TN so mostly just sounds like the voice I’d expect any glamorous woman to have in a velvet walled cabaret (whiskey and honey).
Don’t care for background music
I have been a listener for years, recently I notice I don’t enjoy listening because of the background music that has been added. I find it distracting and hard to concentrate on what is being said.