Listener Reviews

I started listening a long time ago and this podcast has ONLY GOT BETTER! If you prefer your true crime sans witty banter this is the podcast for you!

I can’t wait to get into my car Monday morning for my LA commute to work ( I know sounds strange ) because SFTC latest podcast is out. It’s the little things in life that keep me going! Love Erica’s voice and the way she tells the story.

I listen to a bunch of podcasts - true crime being one of the most. Erica and team do a phenomenal job with showing the juman side of even the worst. She is always a sound for the victims and I really enjoy the additional local history she adds to the episodes, it helps bring the full picture into place. Not to mention her sultry voice is comforting when she’s discussing the horrific details which I think adds to me enjoying the show.

Best true crime podcast out there! Episodes are well researched and offer a balanced and always sympathetic approach. Erica’s delivery has ruined all other podcasts for me because her voice is incredible! Her empathetic nature shines through always. Go listen now!

I love everything about SFTC. Erica's soothing drawl literally sets the tone for these southern true crime stories. This podcast is a "must listen" for me every week.

I found this podcast years ago and was an immediate subscriber. I enjoy this well researched and presented podcast. The information is thorough and never biased towards the criminal even when sharing details of how this person came into a life of crime.

The negative reviews regarding the hosts “personal views” are most likely from keyboard warriors who want to be offended. People who seek a negative slant. This is a great podcast and host. She had a beautiful voice and is a great story teller. The issue happens when people get upset that someone’s personal opinion do not laugh with theirs. Freedom is great, when we get what we (an individual) gets what we want. If you cannot tolerate someone’s opinion, UNSUBSCRIBE from life, metaphorically speaking. Please do not kill your self. Humans have feelings, emotions and believe it or not, opinions.

This is hands down my favorite podcast!

I am so glad I started listening to this podcast late. I can binge whenever and don’t have to wait on new stories!! Erica is a gifted story teller, who is fun and easy to listen to. I love this podcast!!!

All look forward to the next episode

One of my favorite podcasts! I’ve been listening since episode 27. Don’t let the nasty reviews stop you from listening. Erica, Haley, and staff tell amazing stories and well researched.

What I love most about this podcast is the in depth research done on where the crime took place. It sets the stage for the story in the true Southern storytelling tradition. I know I listen to true crime because I want to try and know why. Erica and Haley’s in depth research helps the listener put things in perspective. Erica is always so respectful of the victim, the victims family, and present facts I an unbiased as possible way. Again, the BEST true crime podcast out there!

The amount of research and effort that goes into each episode is amazing! Always ensuring the facts are presented and the victim is the main focus. Thank you Erica! you rock- never change!

Love the sass

This is one of my favorite crime podcasts! When I found it I binged all the episodes. It’s GREAT! I love the deep dive into the background information! It gives me clues as to why the killer may have done what they did. So AMAZING!!

Erica does such a lovely job of honoring the victims and telling the true story. I appreciate her humanity in telling the background and context of a the person who committed the crime. Context matters. The “why” matters. Erica is truly wonderful and SFTC is one of the very best true crime podcasts.

Erica has a voice of silk. She’s a storyteller. She will tell you the Whole story and maybe a little opinion too! Absolutely my favorite

Addictive and excellent! Podcaster has excellent, soothing voice and tells the tales in perfect order and balance.

I agree with you, Erica - true crime is about the storytelling, not the graphic pictures.

I have been listening to Erica and SFTC for several years. It is my absolute favorite. I love the extra information, especially background about the location, victim(s), and the killer(s).

I love the way Erica tells these stories. The cases are always well researched and tactfully shared. One of top fave true crime podcasts!

This pod is in my regular weekly downloads. SFTC notifications of new episodes have me racing to my pod library to listen. Always a Great job telling the victims stories but also helping listeners have some insight into what “may” have contributed to the killers behavior. One question that alot of families ask when they lose a loved one, especially from murder , is “Why”? You offer some great history/back ground that can often help answer (not excuse) the horrible crime(s). Keep doing what you’re doing Erica! I for one, love your story telling and coverage!

I read a bunch of reviews complaining about Erica’s opinions on HER podcast. I personally enjoy that she says what I’m thinking. HOWEVER when I disagree with her opinion, it does not magically make it a bad podcast. If you want a podcast that’s just the facts and NO personality, then go listen to that. Just because you don’t agree with something, it doesn’t make it in inherently bad. When did we all become a bunch of whiners?!? This is a great podcasts that gives you all the facts and spends time on all sides of a story and the narrator has an awesome southern accent to boot!

This is the first true crime podcast I have listened to. I've tried a couple others, but they didn't hook me in like this podcast. It is well researched, and Erica is thoughtful and presents the evidence in an unbiased, respectful, and compelling manner. Also her voice is like butter! Once you start listening you'll know what I'm talking about! Give it a try. You won't be disappointed!