Reviews

Rate Show
Awesome podcast!
It is so hard to listen to just how broken our judicial system is. It’s infuriating and ridiculous. Hopefully, the truth will prevail and Leo will be able to go home to his family. Great job Gilbert and Kelsey. We are rooting for you all!
Incredible reporting
This podcast has me talking back to it so you know it’s excellent. I audibly gasp and get outraged. I really hope Leo gets out and in the meantime this is an excellent description and takedown of the legal scene in central Florida. True investigative and yet compassionate reporting. I have grown a bad taste for true crime in recent months but I’m glad I took a chance on Bone Valley.
Excellent podcast
Really well done. Gripping story told well.
Amazing
This podcast is amazing. So very well done. They did the work not reporting on what someone else reported on.
Wow!!
So far this is second best to “root of evil” my heart bleeds for Leo.
Absolutely superb
Precision storytelling from the jump. Best podcast of the year.
Best crime podcast in years
I cry each episode at the failure of the legal system. It enrages me. Thank you for your fight and determined for justice.
Incredible Podcast
This is the best podcast I've heard. I am absolutely disgusted with the state of Florida and also not surprised with their behavior in this case. Justice for Leo. Justice for Michelle.
Incredibly Well Done
This is the best true crime podcast I have listened to hands down. It is compelling, well written, and thoroughly investigated. This podcast is every bit as captivating and important as Serial and S1 Up & Vanished and should be talked about more!
So good.
One of the best podcasts I’ve ever listen to
Important
Honestly one of the most compelling podcast I have listened to. A must listen on so many levels!!
Heart breakingly good
This podcast has made me bawl at least three times. I pray for all involved, especially Leo — it is unbelievable, hard to comprehend.
Moving and Heartbreaking
This podcast needs to get all the attention it deserves. This case is so heartbreaking, I was crying in the first episode. The pace of the story, the writing, the interviews are perfect. This has become my favorite podcast. I hope they continue to fund meaningful, important stories to tell after this season.
Amazing
This podcast is on a different level of being great. The audio, writing, editing etc. all so good
Great Podcast
This podcast is one of the best I have listened to but why won’t Episode 7 play? I subscribe and it will not play the episode, anyone else having this issue?
Must listen
One of the best podcasts I have listened to, period. Amazing reporting of an important story.
Phenomenal!
The writing on this is hands down the best true crime podcast I’ve ever heard. Despite consuming copious amount of true crime pods, nothing has hooked and made me want to binge like this since Serial. Gripping story aside, the flow of this pod is incredible. It’s so easy to follow and the story is so intriguing. Well done Gilbert Scott, amazing work!! A true gem. Please, keep going!!
Leo's prayer for jeremy
Wow. I started crying when I heard him speak about wanting to forgive jeremy and wanting god to show him love for the first time. Leo inspires me to be better and to never lose hope. I truly hope this ends with him free and working towards happiness again.
Your house will be spotless
Throw some headphones in and get ready for a serious binge.
You Need to Hear This Story!!
Thank you for perseverance in reporting this terrible injustice to Mr Schofield. Amazing story, praying for the Schofields nightmare to relent.
How does this happen??
That’s my review. How does this happen??
Florida?
I’m sorry, is Florida even a real state? This has me concerned with a larger issue of criminality within the legal system in one of our best known states. I’m sure it is pervasive and in every state prosecuting office, but this injustice seems flagrant. I get more frustrated with each episode because I know I’m only going to hear about how some good ol’ boy judge or lawyer is colossally ignorant with borderline IQ <70, but I CANNOT put this down because it is produced and carried out so well. Shame on Florida, have some pride
Favorite yet!
I have listened to several podcasts about exonerating someone in jail. Usually by episode three, I lose interest and think the Podcaster is stretching for a story. This one is awesome, and enraging - in the right way. Can't wait for each Wednesday!
Good stuff
Really enjoying this podcast, very well done. Is the theme song available for download?? Really dig it